Quotations using the same grade name can differ in diameter tolerance, supply condition, surface quality and cutting service.
Technical assessment
Quotations using the same grade name can differ in diameter tolerance, supply condition, surface quality and cutting service.
Practical example and verification method
Do not directly compare kilogram prices when one quotation is for full lengths and the other for cut blanks. Separate the stock, cutting service, waste and machining time required to obtain the same net component quantity. First confirm that both quotations satisfy the same grade and dimensional requirements. Compare the machining allowance resulting from their supply tolerances. Cut stock may appear more expensive yet reduce total stock purchases or workshop time. Assess payment and delivery terms separately from technical compliance. Record the net component quantity on which the decision is based; comparisons using different batch sizes can be misleading.
Order information and decision limits
Compare total usable-part cost, including material, yield loss, cutting, machining and logistics. Normalise prices with unclear units to a common kilogram, metre or piece basis first.
Comparing stainless steel bar quotations
Quotations using the same grade name can differ in diameter tolerance, supply condition, surface quality and cutting service.
What should this enquiry include?
Compare total usable-part cost, including material, yield loss, cutting, machining and logistics.
